news
North Dakota State UniversitySearch
NDSU Extension Service
ND Agricultural Experiment Station
NDSU Agriculture CommunicationArchive

May 5 , 2005

Soybean Planting Trial Provides Production Advice

Soybean planting time is near in North Dakota and farmers need to review their strategies for establishing a 2005 crop successfully, a North Dakota State University agronomy expert says.

A six-year soybean planting trial that NDSU recently completed could help growers with those plans, according to Greg Endres, an NDSU Extension Service area agronomist.

NDSU conducted the trial to evaluate options for planting and establishing soybeans in central North Dakota. The trial examined planting options that included row spacing, planting rates and dates, and tillage systems. In addition, the trial examined the performance of different varieties based on relative maturity. Research agronomists Bob Henson, Mark Halvorson and Eric Eriksmoen conducted the trial at the NDSU Carrington, Minot and Hettinger Research Extension Centers.

Here are some highlights of the trial:

  • From 1999 to 2001, soybeans grown at 6- or 7-inch row spacing (solid-seeded) averaged 5 percent greater yield than 18- or 21-inch rows, and 10 percent greater yield than 30-inch rows. The trial was conducted four times from 2002 to 2004 at Carrington and Minot. Yield with 6- or 7-inch row spacing averaged 4.6 bushels/acre, or 8 percent greater yield, compared with 12- or 14-inch rows. However, solid-seeded soybeans provided a statistically significant yield advantage only half the time.
  • During the 1999 to 2001 growing seasons, soybeans planted at 200,000 pure live seeds (pls)/acre yielded 6 percent and 15 percent greater than yields with the planting rates of 150,000 and 100,000 pls/acre, respectively. From 2002 to 2004 at Carrington and Minot, only one of four times the trial was conducted showed a yield increase with 225,000 pls/acre, compared with planting at 175,000 pls/acre.
  • At Carrington from 1999 to 2001, soybeans planted during mid-May (May 18 to 21) improved yield an average of 2.3 bushels/acre, or 6 percent, compared with yield from planting during the first week of June. Average yield with ‘Traill’ (0.0 relative maturity) declined 5 percent when planted late, while yield with ‘Daksoy’ (00.5 relative maturity) was similar between planting periods.
  • From 2002 to 2004 at Carrington, soybeans planted from May 10 to 15 did not provide a yield advantage, compared with planting 10 to 15 days later (May 20 to 30). Due to a more favorable soil environment for plant establishment, soybeans planted during the last half of May generally resulted in less time needed for stand establishment, greater plant density and similar date of physiological maturity time, compared with the earlier planting time. However, in one of three times the trial was conducted, ‘Barnes’ (0.3 relative maturity) had an 8 bushel/acre, or 19 percent, greater yield when planted May 10, compared with May 20, while ‘Walsh’ (0.0 relative maturity) had a similar yield between planting dates.
  • No-till soybean yield was higher, compared with minimum till, at Minot and Hettinger from 1999 to 2001. No-till soybeans averaged 25 bushels/acre, compared with minimum till at 19 bushels/acre, for a 6-bushel or 25 percent yield advantage with no-till soybeans. The no-till yield increase likely was due to additional stored soil moisture available to the crop.

Endres says the trial shows that reducing soybean row spacing provides a yield advantage, compared with 30-inch rows, so soybean growers will have to examine advantages and disadvantages when deciding on solid-seeded versus narrow-row spacings.

The trial results also adequately confirm NDSU’s recommendation to establish 150,000 plants/acre, he says. He suggests that growers take plant counts after the soybean crop has emerged to determine the optimum seeding rate for their farm to achieve the recommended plant density consistently.

He says other recommendations from the trial results include:

  • Plant a soybean variety with a relative maturity rating during mid-May
  • Plant when soil temperature is near or above 50 degrees and will stay that way following planting to help establish an adequate plant stand
  • Consider no-till production in areas of the state that consistently struggle with adequate soil moisture, especially during mid to late summer.

For more information about the trial, contact the NDSU Carrington Research Extension Center at (701) 652-2951 or recenter@ndsuext.nodak.edu. Contact your county or area NDSU Extension Service office for recommendations on establishing soybeans successfully.

###

NDSU Agriculture Communication

Source: Greg Endres, (701) 652-2951, gendres@ndsuext.nodak.edu
Editor: Ellen Crawford, (701) 231-5391, ecrawfor@ndsuext.nodak.edu


Columns

BeefTalk

Prairie Fare

Plains Folk

Hortiscope

Market Advisor:

Crop

Livestock

 

North Dakota State University
NDSU Agriculture Communication
NDSU Extension Service
ND Agricultural Experiment Station