news
North Dakota State UniversitySearch
NDSU Extension Service
ND Agricultural Experiment Station
NDSU Agriculture CommunicationArchive

December 14, 2006

Hortiscope

Ronald C. Smith, Horticulturist
NDSU Extension Service

Q: The city where I live is expanding a road and letting people take the boxelder trees lining the road. The trees are tall, so they would be expensive to move. I’ve been told that only the female trees with seeds attract boxelder bugs. Do males attract the bugs? Is there a machine large enough to move the trees? Any idea about the percentage of trees that survive a move such as this? (e-mail reference)

A: Why anyone would want boxelder trees is beyond me, but as the saying goes, to each his own. Boxelder bugs do have a preference for female trees, but I've seen a lot of uneducated bugs hanging around male boxelder trees. In fact, I’ve seen boxelder bugs hanging on trees of many species. Boxelder bugs are not the brightest bugs to come out of an incomplete metamorphosis! Trees that size that have been in the same location for a decade or more without any root pruning will be very difficult to remove successfully. Large tree spades rarely are available, except in metro areas where large tree movement is commonplace and planned in advance. In your situation, I would be surprised if 10 percent would survive such a move, and I'm sure it wouldn't be cheap.

 

Q: I came across your Web site while doing some online research. I wanted to bring to your attention that it is a federal violation to use mothballs or ammonia for any wildlife control. Hope you can get the information corrected on your wildlife (and cat) control tips. I wrote an article about the use of mothballs and ammonia. Here is the article.

Mothballs for Critters? No Way!

Working in the nuisance wildlife control business allows me to discover some very strange methods that homeowners try when dealing with their problem animals. I could write a book on the bizarre concoctions and absolutely silly ideas I have seen, and it would be titled "How not to solve urban wildlife problems," as none of these ridiculous methods have any effectiveness. I would like to share a bit of information on one of the most popular, but not effective, methods that people will use when they try to "scare off" mice, rats, or other animals that may be in or around their homes. Mothballs. Besides the fact they do not work for anything other than moths, here are some things to keep in mind. Mothballs pose a serious health hazard for people, pets, and animals. It is a federal offense to use them for any type of animal control. If a chemical, poison or commercial product of any kind does not list the particular animal on the label, it is a federal and EPA violation to use it for that purpose (that includes ammonia). Besides the negative environmental impact, the danger to humans is a major concern. The label on mothballs mentions (if you look hard enough) that it is against the law to use the product for anything except control of moths in articles of clothing. Mothballs are a distinctive smelling, volatile solid used to repel moths. Mothballs, which are classified as a pesticide, may look like candy to a child. Mothballs are poisonous when eaten and seizures can develop in less than one hour. Mothballs contain 100 percent of either naphthalene or paradichlorobenzene. Both ingredients produce harmful effects when they enter your system through inhalation. Irritation to nose, throat and lungs, headache, confusion, excitement or depression, and liver and kidney damage can result from exposure to mothball vapors during a long period of time.

Mothballs containing naphthalene are of special concern because naphthalene can promote a breakdown of red blood cells resulting in hemolytic anemia. Hemolytic anemia in mild form may cause fatigue. In more severe cases, it can cause acute kidney failure. Young children are at particular risk. Poisonings have been reported following dressing infants in clothing that was stored with naphthalene mothballs, suggesting that absorption of naphthalene may occur through the skin. It is impossible to miss the "danger" warnings on the packaging, but people still toss them around their homes without thinking twice about it. The warning label on mothball products reads "avoid prolonged breathing of vapors." This label is at odds with the normal use of mothballs. By the very nature of their ingredients, mothballs give off strong odors (vapors you can smell). These vapors tend to fill the entire home, making it nearly impossible to avoid prolonged breathing of vapors unless you live outdoors. Health studies have determined that if you can smell the mothballs, the vapors are at dangerous levels to humans. The situation is complicated further when mothballs are placed in closets or rooms with poor ventilation because the vapors build to high concentrations. Vapors are absorbed by clothes, blankets and sheets, resulting in direct exposure when you are around these items. The vapors are "heavier" than air, so the dangerous vapors constantly "bleed" down through your home when using them in an attic. I can guarantee that everyone in the house will become violently ill before the squirrel, raccoons or bats move out. Don't be foolish enough to try this nonsense. If you wish to repel moths and other insects, cedar blocks or chips are just as effective, offering an ecofriendly and safe method. Sorry, they don't chase away critters. The only answer to critter control is to trap them and seal off the openings into the structure. Trapping or otherwise eliminating the problem animal simply opens up the site for the next one if the holes are not repaired. Exclusion is the only solution for animal problems. Please excuse my use of the following "technical" information, but it adds to the serious nature of this article.

Naphthalene

Naphthalene, also known as tar camphor, is a white crystalline solid with a distinctive mothball odor. Naphthalene is available to the public as a pest repellent and frequently is contained in mothballs, mothflakes and toilet bowl deodorizers. Naphthalene can enter your system through inhalation, skin absorption, ingestion, and eye and skin contact. Headache, nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, malaise, confusion, anemia and renal disease are typical symptoms of naphthalene exposure. Naphthalene may produce possible damage to eyes, liver, kidneys, skin, red blood cells and the central nervous system. Hemolytic anemia, caused by the breakdown of the red blood cells, has been reported following immediate and long-term exposure. In more severe cases, hemolytic anemia can cause acute kidney failure. Cataracts also have been reported in workers acutely exposed to naphthalene by inhalation and ingestion.

Paradichlorobenzene

Paradichlorobenzene is a white, solid crystal with a wet, oily surface. It is volatile and gives off penetrating mothball-like odors. Paradichlorobenzene is commonly found in mothballs, moth crystals, and in diaper, toilet and room deodorizers. Inhalation may result in headache, swollen eyes, stuffy head, anorexia (loss of appetite), nausea, vomiting, and throat and eye irritation. With prolonged skin contact, allergies and skin irritation have been reported. Symptoms from ingestion include nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, liver and kidney damage, and methemoglobianemia (which interferes with the uptake of oxygen). Chronic exposures to very high levels of para-DCB can result in liver and kidney damage. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has concluded that para-DCB may be reasonably anticipated to be a carcinogen. The state of California has gone further and declared this compound to be a human carcinogen, although there is no direct evidence from human studies to indicate that this compound is a human carcinogen. These determinations were made based on the results of animals showing that long-term exposure resulted in cancer in treated laboratory animals. Also, other animal studies indicate the possibility of birth defects at high level exposures. I certainly hope sharing this information will promote a safer environment around your home. The simple fact is that mothballs do not solve your critter problem, but pose some serious health concerns for humans, pets and other wildlife. Outdoor use in and around your garden would produce very short-term benefits because the active ingredients vaporize very quickly outdoors. Besides being illegal to use for animals, mothballs are a poor choice from both health and environmental standpoints. (e-mail reference)

A: Thanks for the heads up. That information you mention being on the Web site is old, as well as wrong and is not given any more. I'll request our Webmaster, Dave Rice, purge any reference to this from the archives. Your article will appear in our local newspapers as well. Again, thanks for calling this to my attention. As an owner of three spoiled cats, I can't imagine doing anything that would be harmful to them.

 

Q: There is a 50-foot cedar that I would like to save from the dozers. Do you think it's possible? If so, what time of year and how deep do you think the root system is? Any information would be of great help. My house mover, who moves a lot of trees, says he can do it. What are the chances? (e-mail reference)

A: That certainly is a tree worth trying to save because it is a beauty! If your house mover has the experience moving such large trees, have him do so. Move the tree in early spring while the tree is dormant. If properly done, the tree will have to be hand-dug and moved like a house. The chances that the tree will survive are better than 50 percent. I've seen it successfully done once, but that was 25 years ago. It was moved by someone who also moved houses in Ohio. Traffic control/diversion was an added challenge, so don't overlook that or the local law enforcement folks might not take too kindly to your actions, no matter how noble. Get all the details taken care of well ahead of moving the tree.

 

Q: We have a new home with a mature crab apple tree that is heavily covered with sucker growth. Last year’s apple crop was very small and many apples were diseased. My question is about pruning. How much of the length of each sucker should I prune? How much should be removed? Should the tree be pruned in late spring as you said? (e-mail reference)

A: Excess sucker growth is not a good sign for the well-being of a tree. It is usually an indication the tree is in a state of serious decline. I was incorrect if I said that late spring is the time to remove the suckers. The suckers should be removed in early spring, before new growth begins. Pruning when the tree is in leaf opens it up to the roving pathogens that are going to get established in such a weakened tree. All sucker growth should be removed. You should prune the branches as needed, but do not remove more than 25 percent to 30 percent of the branching system per season. It is better to prune too little than too much. If you prune too much, it encourages more sucker growth.

 

Q: We recently returned from a trip to Oahu and We brought back from a trip to Oahu two packets of hibiscus branches about 3 inches in length with a couple of leaves growing from the stem. I'm at a loss as to how these should be handled and planted. At this time, we would obviously plant them indoors. I don't know whether to use soil and plant the stem vertically or lay it flat in the moss provided and then cover it with Saran wrap with a few holes in it to encourage humidity and moisture. Can you help? (e-mail reference)

A: Hibiscus easily root using a rooting compound treatment. I would make up a media of sand/peat. Stick them in the media after treating them with the rooting compound. Provide high humidity, bottom heat and consistent moisture levels for the rooting media.

 

Q: I follow your column and enjoy it a lot because many of the problems you discuss cover the Red River Valley. A member of my family bought a farmstead in the Hawley area. The farmstead has five large trees in the yard. These trees were loaded with berries that looked like Juneberries or chokecherries. I have been told that the berries were poisonous because there were so many and that birds are smart and will not touch them. Is there a berry tree out there that has poisonous berries? If so, we think we might cut down the trees. The trees are nicely shaped. I picked Juneberries for many years in the ‘30s and ‘40s. I noticed that Juneberries are available in the new seed catalogs, so I am thinking about starting some to see if they will survive. Would the new Juneberry be worth planting? (Moorhead, Minn.)

A: Birds clean off berries as they ripen, depriving humans of this very nice treat! Are you sure they are not crabapples? Crabapples often get left on the trees until the food supply becomes critical toward the end of winter. Yes, the new Juneberries are worth it! Thanks for writing and being a faithful reader!

 

Q: I purchased a small, ornamental pepper plant from our local nursery around September of this year. The nursery had yellow, orange, purple and red peppers. It was so cute. I repotted the pepper when I got home. Its leaves are drying up and the new leaves are very small. It actually looks almost dead. However, as sad as it looks, the plant is loaded with the red peppers and continues to produce them. What can I do for this plant? It was so cute and I was hoping to decorate the patio with it next summer. (e-mail reference)

A: You probably need to give it more light. These plants eat up all the bright light one can give them. If you can’t place it in a window that gets direct sunlight most of the day (hard to do during winter months), get some artificial lights with automatic timers. The automatic timers will allow you to provide 13 to 15 hours of light per day. That usually will turn the plant around. You also will need a little patience on your part.

###

Source: Ron Smith, (701) 231-8161, ronsmith@ndsuext.nodak.edu
Editor:
Rich Mattern, (701) 231-6136, richard.mattern@ndsu.nodak.edu


Columns

BeefTalk

Prairie Fare

Plains Folk

Hortiscope

Market Advisor:

Crop

Livestock

 

North Dakota State University
NDSU Agriculture Communication
NDSU Extension Service
ND Agricultural Experiment Station